Review by Librarian Robin Silva

A book rarely surprises me, but this one did, delightfully. Why Fish Don’t exist: A Story of Loss, Love, and the Hidden Order of Life by Lulu Miller is not quite a biography, author memoir, science book, or self-help book, but a little bit of all of them and more. Well written, thoughtful, and thoroughly researched.

Seemingly this is a biography of David Starr Jordan, an accomplished scientist who discovered and named nearly a fifth of the worlds’ fish and who suffers numerous personal losses as well as the loss of his life’s work in the 1906 San Francisco earthquake. Miller then searches to find that magic key, a special personality trait that motivates Jordan to take the losses in stride and continue to seamlessly move on with his life when the author herself feels such hopelessness in light of her own losses. But all is not as it appears as the story takes a on a different light confounding both author and reader. Our intrepid author will finally make sense of her findings, and her conclusions illuminate an otherwise dark tunnel, mirroring how many of us might feel in isolation during the COVID pandemic.

You can find this book and many others in the Athenaeum’s online catalog. Click the button below.

Proprietors and Subscribers, if you have read a book recently from the Athenaeum catalog, we would love to share your review. Contact Librarian Robin Silva for more information,

More Book Reviews

In Pursuit of History by the Dietrich American Foundation
Review by Proprietor Gerald W. R. Ward

For more than fifty years, the Dietrich American Foundation of Pennsylvania has played an important role in the world of early American art and material culture. Established in 1963 by H. Richard Dietrich Jr., the collection now contains some 2,385 outstanding examples of early American furniture, silver, paintings, Chinese export porcelain, books, manuscripts, and maps, as well as specialized holdings of Pennsylvania German folk art and objects associated with whaling. This catalogue covering the collection was prepared by ten outstanding scholars under the direction of Deborah Rebuck, the foundation’s curator, and H. Richard Dietrich III, the collector’s son. Over the years, the Foundation generously has placed objects from its collection on loan to more than one hundred museums and institutions, and they continue this practice.

Although the catalogue contains many outstanding objects and documents, the majority are related to the Middle Colonies, especially Pennsylvania. One important exception of intensely local interest is a rare dressing table of ca. 1735-45 signed by Joseph Davis of Portsmouth (cat. 2.5, pp. 110-11). It is a companion piece to a high chest now in the Diplomatic Reception Rooms of the United States Department of State. Although this dressing table has been published before, here we see it in a full-page color photograph taken by noted photographer Gavin Ashworth.

Richard Dietrich Jr. inherited his father’s interest in the Luden’s candy and cough drop business. Over time, he expanded his business enterprises to the point where he could afford to indulge his passion for collecting on a grand scale, a process discussed in detail here. He did so with sensitivity and taste, expanding his initial interest in acquiring historical documents into a more wide-ranging appetite for works of high aesthetic quality. This major catalogue tells both Mr. Dietrich’s personal story as well as chronicling the objects he acquired to share with the nation.


Richard Dietrich III and Deborah M. Rebuck, eds. In Pursuit of History: A Lifetime Collecting Colonial American Art and Artifacts. Philadelphia: Dietrich American Foundation in association with the Philadelphia Museum of Art, 2019. 303 pp.; 215 color illus., timeline. Distributed by Yale University Press, New Haven and London.

Olive, Again by Elizabeth Strout
Review by Research Librarian Carolyn Marvin

Olive, Again by Elizabeth Strout features the return of her prickly character Olive Kittredge from the small town of Crosby, Maine. And we, the reader, are so grateful to Strout and so ready to revisit the many villagers she encounters. It is a bitter-sweet journey, particularly this time round, as Olive moves into her 70s and 80s and observes and endures the many trials of growing old. Her life and that of those she meets provoke such keen observations, we can only nod with her in agreement.

Strout is a master of character established through gesture, expression and dialogue and in Olive’s dealing with the indignities and frustrations of old age, she has created her masterpiece. Olive is, if nothing else, honest. She speaks the truth, but her honesty is often cutting and lacking in empathy. In this new volume, the wisdom and balance that comes with age, allows her to observe and comment upon others as well as to reflect upon herself, in acerbic, but accurate ways. Sitting in the coffee shop, she muses:

When you get old, you become invisible. It’s just the truth. And yet it’s freeing in a way. You go through life and you think you are something. Not in a good way, and not in a bad way. But you think you are something, and then you see that you are no longer anything. To a waitress with a huge hind end you’ve become invisible. And it’s freeing.

When you fall as an “older” person, you go down like a felled tree. It takes time for your brain to compute “I am falling” as you simultaneously crash to the ground. And if, like Olive, there is no one around to hear your cries, you struggle to raise yourself but just can’t (“get up you damned fool”), you crawl to whatever is there that can be used as leverage. For Olive, it is that outdoor spigot that her late husband reluctantly installed at her request (he thought it foolish) which helps Olive get back into the house. And then into an assisted living facility, a difficult thing for this proud woman to accept.

I could visit Olive again and again. As we leave her writing down memories on an old typewriter, we wonder, could there be another book coming?

The Road Not Taken by Max Boot
Review by Proprietor Alan Bennett

This is a must read for all who were physically or emotionally involved in the period from the Cuban Missile Crisis and the Vietnam War. Ed Lansdale was a true visionary and American patriot who was continuously humbled and ignored. Too bad he isn’t alive to advise our current leaders!

The Lost Gutenberg by Margaret Leslie Davis
Review by Proprietor David Sanderson

I would highly recommend this book. It traces the adventures of one of the 45 known copies of the Gutenberg Bible. It gives an account of the fortunes and misfortunes of the sometimes obsessive owners of the bible, culminating with the Dohenneys, of Teapot Dome notoriety. Along the way, there is much information about the development of the printing process.


Golden Hill by Francis Spufford
Review by Proprietor Cindy Bufithis

This historical fiction book set in colonial New York dazzles the reader with a roller coaster plot, vivid language and authentic settings. The main character, the handsome, but mysterious young man named Mr. Smith steps off an English ship and proceeds to the office of the preeminent shipping company, where he presents a bill of credit for one thousand pounds, a fortune which the company is loath to pay.  Stalling for time, they insist on waiting for confirmation from England. Meanwhile the local business community consisting of established Dutch traders and the more recent English gentry trieto ferret out this man’s motivations. What are  Mr. Smith’s intentions? The author employs colorful metaphors, Dutch phrases, sensory language and cultural details to create cinematic effects which captivate and mystify. For Mr. Smith is not who he seems and before this tale ends we will discover that the narrator has a point of view we don’t expect.

Did you know? Portsmouth Athenaeum Proprietors and Subscribers are able to borrow books out of the library? Not a member of the Athenaeum? Join today!